Best Actor
A lead actor must play a leading role, with substantial stage time, character development, and centrality to the story line. A lead actor must also play a significant part in the leadership of the production and the development of younger actors.
| Year | Name | For |
|---|---|---|
| 2010 | Seth Hair | Pseudolus - A Funny Thing...Forum |
| 2009 | R. H. Wilhoit | Hamlet - Hamlet |
| 2008 | R. H. Wilhoit | Mick Hamilton - Steel Pier |
| 2007 | Seth Hunt | Billy Crocker - Anything Goes |
| 2006 | Seth Hunt | Henry Jekyll & Edward Hyde - Jekyll & Hyde |
| 2005 | Dennis Burnett | Oliver Warbucks - Annie |
| 2004 | Dustin Brown | Joe - Working |
| 2003 | Jordan Fox | Baptista - Taming Of The Shrew |
| 2002 | Adam Gutkin | Whiteside - The Man Who Came To Dinner |
| 2001 | Brad Gratton | Dacron - Clumsy Custard Horror Show |